Is that free phone deal too good to be true? Find your 36-month number before you sign anything
A listener with an iPhone 11 and a tight Christmas budget asked whether free phone ads are legit. Here’s the three-minute bill check that tells you whether a phone deal is actually good.
ChatGPT/Kim Komando
🤯 WOW! The price on a phone ad is the least important number in the deal. The one that matters is hiding on your bill: what you’ll pay over 36 months. Most people have never added it up. Do it once, and you’ll know in three minutes whether any deal, “free” or not, is worth it.
The Short Version: Ignore the sticker price. Multiply your real monthly bill by 36. Steps below.
📖 Read time: 2 minutes
“Hi, Kim, Money’s tight, especially with Christmas right around the corner. I have an iPhone 11. I see ads for getting a new free phone. Is it one of those things that is too good to be true?” — Jeremy in Boston
Jeremy, smart move asking before you sign. Most “free phone” deals are real. They’re not free.
- Your carrier pays off the phone with bill credits over two to three years.
- To get them, you usually trade in your old phone and move up to a pricier plan.
- Leave early, and the credits stop. You owe what’s left.
Say the free phone plan runs $90 a month and a straight deal runs $59. That “free” phone costs you $1,116 over three years.
My rule for any deal: Ignore the sticker. Find the 36-month number.
🧮 Find your real number in 3 minutes
Grab your bill. Add up your plan, any device payment, phone insurance and taxes and fees.
Multiply that total by 36. Every $10 a month is $360. That’s your cash walking out the door.
💡 5 more ways to cut your bill
- Make sure you can leave. Open Settings > General > About and scroll to Carrier Lock. “No SIM restrictions” means it’s unlocked.
- Check your data. Settings > Cellular shows your usage. Mostly on Wi-Fi? Downsize that giant plan.
- Stop sneaky data use. When Wi-Fi gets weak, your iPhone quietly switches to cellular. Go to Settings > Wi-Fi, scroll down and turn off Connectivity Assist. (Formerly Wi-Fi Assist.)
- Hunt for ghost lines. An old tablet or watch line nobody uses still bills you monthly. Cancel it.
- Try a new battery first. Check Settings > Battery > Battery Health. Under 80%? Apple replaces an iPhone 11 battery for $89. Way cheaper than a new phone.
Good news, Jeremy: Your iPhone 11 still gets security updates. Don’t panic-buy.
✅ What a straight deal looks like
Here’s what I use. Consumer Cellular, a sponsor of my show, doesn’t do “free.” It does everyday low prices. (It’s my carrier, too. They buy airtime. They don’t buy my opinion.)
- A new 5G phone plus an unlimited everything plan for $59 a month or less on eligible phones.
- 36-month EasyPay financing, no trade-in required.
- When the 36 months are up, you own the phone, not the carrier.
Compare that to your 36-month number. If you’re paying well over $59 a month, see how much you’d save.*
✅ Use promo code KIM50 for an extra $50 off service at ConsumerCellular.com/Kim.
🗣️ Text/post this stat: Every $10 a month on your phone bill adds up to $360 over three years. Find your 36-month number before you sign anything. Get smarter about tech at GetKim.com.
📩 Send this to someone who’s about to sign up for a “free” phone this Christmas.